Skip to main content

NYCFC needs a leadership group, and there are multiple choices to choose from

Multiple players could form an NYCFC leadership group.
ByCaitlyn Chale
James Sands of NYCFC
James Sands of NYCFC | Adam Hunger/GettyImages

David Villa. Alexander Ring. Sean Johnson. Maxime Chanot. Thiago Martins. All of these players have been the captain of New York City FC since the inaugural season in 2015. Although not all were named, as Chanot was never announced as the captain despite wearing the armband, all of these players led the Pigeons on and off the pitch.

But now, after Martins' departure this offseason, the Bronx side is in need of a new captain. There are a few options that NYCFC could choose from, like Matt Freese and James Sands. Both have worn the armband in the past, especially Sands. However, the club must consider to not only name a captain, but have a leadership group.

A possible NYCFC leadership group

For starters, NYCFC is likely to go through more turnover before the Sprint Season begins in February. The club has already announced the roster decisions, meaning there are fewer players who would be considered for the leadership group. Keaton Parks is also leaving, and he is someone who has been a leader for the players on the roster, on and off the pitch. If he had stayed after Martins' departure, then he is someone who could have been considered to be named the captain.

Instead, the long-time midfielder is gone. But Freese and Sands could easily be part of the leadership group. The goalkeeper often acts like a second captain despite not wearing the armband. He is always directing the backline, and he is always there for his teammates. Sands has natural leadership, as there was a reason he wore the armband when he was younger.

Sure, at the time, it was thought there were better candidates for the NYCFC captain. However, the midfielder still had no issue with older players turning to him. His quiet leadership abilities help a squad regardless of whether he is the first captain or part of the leadership group.

Looking at others, Nicolás Fernández Mercau and Aiden O'Neill are great leaders and could be a part of the group. But the easy answer, depending on whether he returns or retires, as to who would be part of such a group, would be Maxi Moralez. The Argentine has been a leader for many years and could have been the captain. He pulls the strings in the midfield, which leads him to direct the lineup when it comes to the play. His age and wisdom make him someone his teammates can approach. Plus, Moralez just looks like someone who should be in charge.

Of the mentioned NYCFC players, any of them could be the captain. It is unknown, though, who it will be. Freese and Sands, though, are the top choices for 2027. But everyone mentioned could form a leadership coalition and help the squad through 2027 and beyond.

Add us as a preferred source on Google