Thiago Martins is the first player to depart NYCFC after the 2026 season

Well, the end is officially here for some players. New York City FC made a flurry of roster-decision announcements on Thursday. One such player who was announced to be leaving the club was Thiago Martins.

This was believed to be a possibility when the Brazilian announced, after the final home game of the 2026 season, that he did not know whether he would be here next season. So, after five seasons and 174 appearances in all competitions, Martins is saying goodbye to the Big Apple.

“I’m grateful for my time with New York City FC,” Martins said to newyorkcityfc.com. “It’s been an honor to represent this Club and wear the captain’s armband. I want to thank all my teammates who have stood by my side throughout these five seasons, as well as the staff, everyone behind the scenes, and the fans for their support. New York City will always hold a special place in my heart and in the hearts of my family.”

Thiago Martins is leaving NYCFC

It is unclear whether this was a mutual or one-sided decision. Based on Martins' initial comments, it is possible that NYCFC decided to not offer him a new contract. Perhaps the team wanted a new deal where the defender would make less money. Maybe he did not want that.

After all, while he is a top defender in Major League Soccer, it took fans a while to get behind him and appreciate his talent. The problem was that he was a Designated Player until this summer, when his contract was bought down.

As a DP, Martins was expected to be the best of the best in MLS. However, he was not at the beginning, and that frustrated fans. Over time, he improved and became one of the top center-backs. But it was still problematic that he was being paid top dollar and was utilizing that coveted roster spot.

Hence, with that information in mind, money might truly be the reason why Martins and NYCFC did not agree to a new deal. The captain had been critical to the backline, aside from some big mistakes, and he can still play at a high level.

Now, the Pigeons must find a top center-back, as James Sands is the only one who can play there at a high level and has proven that he can be a starter. Tayvon Gray is needed as the right-back, and Kai Trewin has not proven that he should be a starter yet. Then, Raul Gustavo is better as a depth piece.

The most important thing is that NYCFC does not spend an arm and a leg on the next center-back. Still, it is sad that Martins will not be back, even on a shorter deal through the 2027-2028 season. Sure, because of his contract, he was a controversial defender to have on the roster. However, there is no question that the captain will be missed. He bled sky blue and cared so much for his team and the city.

So, thank you, Martins.

Add us as a preferred source on Google