Skip to main content

Jess Carter officially leaves Gotham FC after a trophy-filled run

After reports emerged that Jess Carter was leaving, Gotham FC officially confirmed that the center-back is departing the club.
ByCaitlyn Chale
Jess Carter, formerly of Gotham FC
Jess Carter, formerly of Gotham FC | Dustin Satloff/GettyImages

A few days ago, reports emerged that Jess Carter and 2026 Goalkeeper of the Year Ann-Katrin Berger are leaving NJ/NY Gotham FC. Obviously, the Bats cannot retain all of their free agents, so it was sad to hear that. And now, the club has officially confirmed one of the departures.

After two and a half years as a center-back and left-back for the NJ/NY team, Carter is leaving as a free agent. Gotham FC announced this on Wednesday as she officially moves to Bay FC. She was a major reason as to why the team won the NWSL Shield this season, and she has been a major part of the backline since she joined in the summer of 2024.

Jess Carter leaves Gotham FC

During her time with Gotham, Carter played mostly as a center-back but also played as the right-back when needed. Her grit and dedication to her craft meant that fans would always see her play at her best, or at least give it her all. It did not matter the competition, as the defender was always ready to go. After all, she did make 83 appearances in all competitions.

Carter was also a critical part of the Bats' trophy wins during her time in New Jersey. With Gotham, she won the CONCACAF W Champions Cup, NWSL Championship, NWSL Challenge Cup, and the NWSL Shield.

While it would have been better if she had signed a new contract, fans can appreciate what Carter has done for the Bats. Yael Averbuch West, the president of soccer operations, clearly appreciates the center-back's commitment and hard work over the last few years. "Jess has been a big part of what we've accomplished as a club, and we're very thankful for the contributions she's made during her time here," she told gothamfc.com. "She brought a wealth of experience to our backline and helped us compete for and win championships. We appreciate everything she's given to Gotham FC and wish her the best.”

Still, it is interesting that Carter is going across the country to play for a team that has significantly struggled over the last two seasons. It will be a big change, but perhaps she wants the challenge. Of course, one cannot forget about money, either. A stronger contract can always pull someone elsewhere.

Nevertheless, Carter will be missed. Gotham FC was lucky to have her, and now she can show off her talent for a new team.

Add us as a preferred source on Google