Skip to main content

Ann-Katrin Berger and Jordynn Dudley are the Goalkeeper and Rookie of the Year

Gotham FC had two players win 2026 NWSL Awards.
ByCaitlyn Chale
Ann-Katrin Berger of Gotham FC
Ann-Katrin Berger of Gotham FC | Stephen Nadler/ISI Photos/GettyImages

On Wednesday evening, NJ/NY Gotham FC had multiple players up for the NWSL Awards. Ann-Katrin Berger was up for Goalkeeper of the Year, Tierna Davidson was up for Defender of the Year, Jaelin Howell and Rose Lavelle were up for Midfielder of the Year, and Jordynn Dudley was up for Rookie of the Year. In addition, Juan Carlos Amorós was up for Coach of the Year.

It was no shock that the Bats had so many nominees, as the team won the NWSL Shield for the first time this season and had a great year overall. But which Gotham FC stars won an award?

To begin, Berger, Davidson, and Howell were all a part of the Best XI first team, while Lavelle was a part of the Best XI second team. This made sense, as the four of them were nominated for awards this season.

Then, Davidson, Amorós, Howell, and Lavelle did not win their respective awards. But Gotham FC was well represented Wednesday night.

Gotham FC's 20206 NWSL Award winners

Goalkeeper of the Year

Berger won the Goalkeeper of the Year award for the second time in her Gotham FC career. Between the regular season and the playoffs, she only gave up 25 goals in the NWSL. On the other side, she made 88 saves. She also had 11 clean sheets in the regular season, which was the second-most in the league.

The German international was between the sticks for 15 of the NJ/NY side's 18 wins in the regular season, and truly, how she played helped the team finish in first place. It is sad that she is reported to be leaving the club, as there is no Shield without Berger. Some of the saves she made throughout the year were insane, and she always put her body on the line.

When all is said and done, the goalkeeper really had no competition. She deserves this, and there is a reason she has won this award in two of her last three seasons.

Rookie of the Year

On the other hand, there was plenty of competition for Rookie of the Year. But Dudley won out, and it was more for her play on the wings than the typical stats. She scored four goals and had three assists in the regular season, but it was the acts that were not measured that truly revealed her talent.

Her awareness of other players simplified her ability to move up the pitch. Her passes contributed to the attack, and she was not afraid to take on opposing players. It was difficult to contain the winger, which led to her being fouled and winning free kicks quite often.

Dudley was extremely threatening, but also a little unlucky. About 67% of her shots were on target, but she only scored four times. It seemed like she was going to start scoring more after her brace against the North Carolina Courage, but a foot injury cut her season short. Who knows whether she would have scored more, but hopefully, she will score more in 2027.

Meanwhile, Dudley is Gotham FC's third Rookie of the Year in the last four seasons. Jenna Nighswonger won in 2023, and Lilly Reale won in 2025. However, both players left shortly after winning the award, with Nighswonger leaving after two seasons and Reale leaving in the middle of the year. Hopefully, the same thing will not happen to the young winger.

In the end, Gotham FC deserves to have two players win an NWSL Award. 2026 was a great season, and the player recognition, including the Best XI, shows how wonderful the year was.

Add us as a preferred source on Google