Skip to main content

Ann-Katrin Berger and Jess Carter are reportedly leaving Gotham FC

Starters Ann-Katrin Berger and Jess Carter are reported to be leaving Gotham FC. How would this impact the NWSL team?
ByCaitlyn Chale
Jess Carter of Gotham FC
Jess Carter of Gotham FC | Ira L. Black/GettyImages

NJ/NY Gotham FC's magical 2026 season sadly came to an end on Sunday. The Bats lost to the Kansas City Current in the semifinals of the NWSL Playoffs, ending their chase for back-to-back championships. It was still a good year, though, as the Bats won the NWSL Challenge Cup and the NWSL Shield, so there is a lot to be proud of. But now, the team has to immediately turn to 2027, as it has been reported that two major players are leaving the club.

According to reports, Jess Carter and Ann-Katrin Berger are both leaving Gotham FC as free agents. Notbably, the Bats have seven free agents entering the offseason from when free agency opened. Khyah Harper was traded away, and Rose Lavelle signed a contract extension. But of the free agents, losing Carter and Berger can be a big deal.

What are the reports saying, though, about the Gotham FC players?

The possible impact of losing major Gotham FC players

Per Jenna Tonelli of Sports Illustrated, Carter is signing with Bay FC. The center-back will subsequently join a team on the other side of the country that has finished 14th and 13th in the last two years. That is a stark difference from the competitive and trophy-winning NJ/NY team, so it is easy to wonder whether she is looking for a challenge.

Of course, one can wonder whether money was involved. Bay is looking to rebuild their backline, and with the players Gotham has already extended and might be trying to bring back, perhaps the contract was too good to turn down. It is sad, though, as Carter has been a fantastic defender since joining in the summer of 2024.

Sure, she was not perfect, as her slowness sometimes caused issues. Nevertheless, everything else about her defense truly aided Gotham in winning all of the trophies that they have won throughout the last few years.

One thing must be said, though, and that is that the Bats will be absolutely fine losing Carter. It stinks since she is very good, but the NJ/NY side has fantastic defenders like Tierna Davidson and Emily Sonnett, and then some midfielders and forwards have proven they can play in the backline, like Guro Reiten. The big concern is what Gotham FC will do without Berger.

According to Megan Feringa and Melanie Anzidei of The Athletic, Berger is also leaving the Bats after three years with the club. The star goalkeeper will be elsewhere next year, but where exactly is the big question.

There are reports that she has European interest, especially from Manchester City W.F.C. in England. Apparently, the club attempted to sign Berger over the summer. But Gotham thankfully did not sell, as the German international was critical in the NWSL Shield chase.

Meanwhile, it would be interesting on a personal level if she were to head back over the Atlantic, as she and Carter are engaged. If these reported moves do happen, then they would be extremely far from one another.

On a sporting level, though, it is extremely difficult to replace Berger as the goalkeeper. She is on another level, and she is the best goalkeeper in the NWSL. She won the Goalkeeper of the Year award in 2024 and is up for the award again this year. Between her quick reflexes, her ability to save short-range and long-range shots, her game intelligence, and her ability to read opposing players, she had an advantage over others.

Just this season alone, Berger gave up only 25 goals, the fewest of NWSL keepers who played all or most of the season. She also had the lowest goals-allowed average, at 0.86.

It is unknown what Gotham FC will do. Maybe they will bring back Shelby Hogan, who is also a free agent, and have her, Ryan Campbell, and Teagan Wy compete for the starting role. Maybe the club will look elsewhere for the starting keeper. Still, it is difficult to believe that someone will step in and be even close to the talent level of Berger.

Add us as a preferred source on Google