NJ/NY Gotham FC's season wrapped up a week earlier than hoped on Sunday evening, losing to the Kansas City Current 2-1 in the semifinals of the NWSL Playoffs. This means that, come late Saturday night, the Bats' reign as NWSL Champions will come to an end. It was not a completely lost season, as earlier in the year the club captured both the Challenge Cup and the NWSL Shield for the first time in club history.
The 2026 season was the longest in Gotham FC's history, both from a time and games played perspective. A 37-game season stretched across five different competitions that began in London in late January and ended in November in New York City. Stops along the way included a return to Boston for the first time in nine years, a return to Mexico in CONCACAF play, as well as first-ever trips to Denver and Columbus.
And of course, the big showpiece event of 2026 was the Queens Classic in July, where over 42,000 fans watched Gotham not only pull off a 1-0 win over their arch rivals, the Washington Spirit, thanks to a Rose Lavelle golazo, but also saw club legend Sam Kerr make her return after nine years away. Outside of the trophies won, this match was without a doubt the biggest moment of the 2026 campaign and hopefully a glimpse into what is potentially to come in 2028 when the Bats move across the street to Etihad Park.
While there is much to celebrate and positively reflect on in 2026, the ultimate goal of being the first American women's team to win a domestic treble was not in the cards. Given the mixed feelings that many fans are probably feeling, there is plenty of good and bad to look back on and analyze from the 2026 Gotham FC season.
2026 Gotham FC season post-mortem
What went wrong?
The two main culprits for Gotham FC falling short were injuries and a lack of attacking output. Neither is a new problem, with both playing huge roles throughout Juan Carlos Amorós' four years as the head coach. They have overcome the issues in past years, as well as at times earlier this season. Ultimately, both reared their head come playoff time. They weathered the storm against Seattle Reign FC in the quarterfinals. However, once they matched up against a team of a similar talent level in the Current, those problems caught up to them.
Something else that may have caught up to them was the midseason roster shakeup. Yes, big-time players like Denise O'Sullivan, Sam Kerr, and Leila Ouahabi played well and filled big holes when they arrived. But after a quiet offseason that saw them return 20 players from 2025, including all 12 players who saw the field in the 2025 NWSL Championship game, many fans were glad to see some much-wanted roster consistency after constant chopping and changing in recent offseasons.
But as seen in past seasons, the club made several midseason roster changes. They made smaller trades, like Khyah Harper moving to the Houston Dash, and bigger moves like Lilly Reale and Sarah Schupansky moving to Boston Legacy FC in separate deals. And who can forget the controversial saga surrounding Esther González.
These departures unfortunately ended up coinciding with an injury crisis that eventually saw the signings of Meredith Speck, Olivia Wingate, and Tess Boade. And while these players performed admirably and did what they could when called upon, they were clearly not Amorós' preferred options.
What went well?
It's hard to move on from the bitter feeling of losing the last game of a season, but being able to put that to the side and looking at the season as a whole reveals an incredibly successful 2026 for Gotham. The club won their first-ever Challenge Cup in June, ironically by beating Kansas City, and then clinched their first-ever Shield on Decision Day with a 2-0 win over Utah Royals FC. This makes them the third team in league history to have won all three yearly domestic trophies on offer in the NWSL after the North Carolina Courage and Portland Thorns FC.
2026 also saw the emergence of both Jaedyn Shaw and rookie Jordynn Dudley. Shaw set a career high in goal contributions with 18 in 30 games in all competitions. She also finished in top ten in the NWSL Golden Boot race with 11 goals, good enough for a tie for eighth with Evelyn Ijeh, Trinity Byars, and Amanda Gutierres.
Most years, numbers like that would see Shaw in MVP contention, but scoring was at its highest in the league this season by a considerable margin. 15 players registered 10+ goals while 33 players managed 10+ goal contributions, up significantly from five and eight, respectively, in 2025. Some of this can be put down to the expanded schedule and teams beating up on the likes of Boston, Racing Louisville FC, and Chicago Stars FC, who conceded the most goals in 2026. It may also be a sign of the league becoming a much higher-scoring environment.
Meanwhile, Dudley was a true gamechanger for Gotham in her rookie season. The 21-year-old only managed four goals and three assists, but very quickly established herself as an indispensable piece of the starting lineup. When she suffered an injury in training that ended her rookie year with five regular-season games to go, it was clear to see the difference between a Gotham team that had Dudley on the field and one that didn't.
Midge Purce did a very good job in Dudley's absence, but it could be easily argued that a healthy Dudley could have been the difference between the NJ/NY side playing for a championship on Saturday and having their season come to an end.
Other positives included Tierna Davidson returning after missing the vast majority of 2025 due to an ACL injury and immediately getting back to the elite level of defender play that saw her nominated for the NWSL Defender of the Year.
Jaelin Howell built on her breakout 2025 and produced yet another stellar campaign in 2026. While the goalscoring from last season did not carry over, she proved that 2025 wasn't a fluke and that she is definitely one of the elite defensive midfielders in the NWSL.
There are plenty of positives to take from 2026 into 2027, as this was the most successful season in club history. They will also have plenty of opportunities for more silverware next year, too. In addition to the ever-present Shield and Championship, the Bats have qualified for next season's Challenge Cup by winning the Shield in 2026. And, while not 100% official, it is expected that Gotham FC will be taking part in next year's revamped CONCACAF Champions Cup again thanks to winning the Shield or due to their 2025 NWSL Championship win.
