After the roster decisions were released, New York City FC fans knew that was just the start of the changes to the squad. There are some players who should leave, and others might leave for better opportunities. One player whom the club should say goodbye to is Hannes Wolf.
When he joined in 2024, there were questions about whether he was the right signing for NYCFC. In the end, despite some positive moments, he has not lived up to his full potential. Rather than letting him leave for free when his contract is up, the team should instead sell or trade him this offseason.
Hannes Wolf should leave NYCFC
To begin, this is not to say that Wolf is a bad player. Rather, he gets hot and cold throughout the season. But even that is not good enough. In three seasons with NYCFC, he has scored only 22 goals and has just 15 assists. He lacked consistency in his play, and sometimes, it was like Wolf was not on the pitch.
As a player from Europe making about $1.5 million, more was expected from him in the goals and assists department. But one of the biggest issues was his lack of consistency. Again, he had some great moments with NYCFC, especially against the Columbus Crew. Who could forget the match this year when his hat-trick ended the first winless streak this season?
His best season statistically was probably in 2025, when he scored 11 goals and had six assists. But in 2024, he scored five goals, and then six goals this year. The low number is not what one wants to see from a player making so much money.
Even Wolf's passes and crosses would go haywire. He was not always the best at finding his teammates. Again, he would play well in some matches, but for most of the 2026 season and his NYCFC career as a whole, he was only okay or not good enough to be on the pitch.
Plus, with the money he is making, as Wolf's guaranteed compensation in 2026 was $1,510,000, it is difficult to say that he should stick around. If he were making around $200,000, then having him on the roster would not be terrible. However, since he made that much money as an inconsistent player, allowing him to leave would free up salary space. That alone is a major reason to say goodbye.
NYCFC can utilize such a salary for another high goal-scoring player, as they clearly need help in the attack. So, get something back from Wolf, and do so as soon as possible.
