Skyscraper Blues
FanSided

Is it time to be concerned about NYCFC II, or is it too early?

  • NYCFC II started the season well but has faltered
  • The MLS Next Pro side is 2-4-2 after eight matches
ByCaitlyn Chale|
Drew Baiera of NYCFC II
Drew Baiera of NYCFC II | Andrew Katsampes/ISI Photos/GettyImages

When New York City FC II, New York City FC's MLS Next Pro team, began the season, there was plenty of hope for the young side. They began the season with two regular wins and a draw that led to a penalty kick shootout win, creating hope that the Baby Pigeons would continue to build off from their successful 2024 campaign, when they made the playoffs for the first time.

However, NYCFC II has not won since March 24. They have lost four of their last five games, with the other being a draw without a penalty kick shootout win. As a result, the team sits in eighth place in the Eastern Conference and has a 2-4-2 record. Since teams in the MLS Next Pro can earn a total of two points when they win a penalty kick shootout after a draw, the Boys in Blue have nine points.

Now, it is not the worst record, for they are right in the middle of the table. Still, starting the season off strongly and then losing four of the next five matches is not the direction the team wants to go. Moreover, they have given up 16 goals during this period and have scored six times.

NYCFC II and early concerns

Therefore, it is time to be concerned about NYCFC II? Is it too soon? Or, similar to NYCFC, is the team just going through a rough patch?

Truthfully, it might be too soon to worry fully. But if NYCFC II continues to struggle over their next few games, then it might be time to worry and be concerned about the team. At the same time, questions surround the defense, for allowing 16 goals in five games is horrible.

Plus, two of the main center-back pairings, Prince Amponsah and Max Murray, are signed with the first team while predominantly playing with the second. Homegrown Drew Baiera also started two of the losses, playing as a fullback.

There are quite a few Homegrowns and young NYCFC players who play for the MLS Next Pro team. Fans want these players to be successful as they prepare and build for the future. It is vital that the club has a winning culture throughout every level, including the academy and NYCFC II.

If the Baby Pigeons continue to struggle, then the club might need to have a conversation about Matt Pilkington. He has been a good head coach, led the team to their first playoff appearance last year, and has a winning mindset. Such a drastic downfall, if it continues, cannot happen though.

Home/NYCFC News